#deadwitness | #pgewitness | Accenture | Anthrax | World Trade Bombings | Explosions | Oracle Corporation | #deadattorney | #deadCEOs | #murder

PLI White Collar Crime 2018: Prosecutors and Regulators Speak I. Introduction


Connecting Success Factors to Bennett

New York, NY
Oct. 3, 2018

PLI White Collar Crime 2018: Prosecutors and Regulators Speak

I. Introduction

Thank you for that kind introduction, and thank you for inviting me to speak here this morning.  Before I begin, I am required to give a standard disclaimer that the views I express here today are my own, and do not necessarily represent the views of the Commission or its staff.[1] 
My remarks today come a little over a year after Stephanie Avakian and I were appointed Co-Directors of the SEC’s Division of Enforcement and just a few days after the close of the first full fiscal year in which we have held our positions.  So this is a fitting time to look back on the work of the Division of Enforcement over the past year and to discuss the Division’s priorities over the next year. 
Many of those who closely follow the work of the Enforcement Division tend to evaluate its effectiveness based on metrics such as the number of enforcement actions the Commission brings each year and the total amount of penalties and disgorgement ordered by the Commission or federal district courts.  These quantitative metrics are of some value in assessing the work of the Division; they certainly provide a rough measure of our overall activity level.  But statistics such as these do not provide a full and meaningful picture of the quality, nature, and effectiveness of our efforts.  Indeed, in my view, when numbers are the primary lens through which our work is viewed, that perspective can be counterproductive. 
So to assess whether the Division’s work is effective in accomplishing the Commission’s mission, Stephanie and I have been moving the conversation to a different set of questions, namely the following:
  • Are our efforts protecting retail investors?
  • To what extent is the Commission holding individuals accountable for violations of the law?
  • Are we keeping pace with technological change?
  • Do the remedies we recommend effectively further enforcement goals?
  • And, are we efficiently allocating the Division’s resources?
This morning, I’d like to focus my remarks on how we think about one of these questions – that is, how particular remedies and relief that the Division of Enforcement recommends to the Commission advance our goals.  In thinking about the effectiveness of the remedies and relief available to the Commission, it is tempting to focus solely on the Commission’s ability to obtain significant financial penalties in enforcement actions.  Large dollar figures attract headlines and some view them as a proxy for how tough we are, and, relatedly, the effectiveness of our enforcement efforts. 
Penalties are important to an effective enforcement regime because they punish wrongdoers and send a message of general deterrence – ensuring that others know that violating the federal securities laws is a losing proposition.  And our activity over just this past year reflects our view that in many instances, to be effective, such penalties need to be substantial.  In fact, just last week, the Commission assessed eight-figure penalties against Walgreens and Tesla, which I’ll address in more detail later this morning.    
While we do seek and obtain some form of monetary relief – whether disgorgement, penalties or both – in most of our actions, non-monetary relief can be highly important to achieving the Commission’s overall goals as well.  For that reason, a case-specific approach to remedies and relief is important, and is exemplified by a number of Commission actions that I will describe during my remarks today.  

II. Non-Monetary Relief

When we think about what overall relief makes the most sense in a given case, we’re guided by these questions:  Does the relief punish bad actors and restore money to harmed investors?  Does it advance the goals of specific and general deterrence?  And does it put into place meaningful protections for investors going forward?  If we have secured a good set of remedies, we can answer each of those questions affirmatively, and to do so often requires looking not just to penalties and disgorgement, but to forms of equitable or remedial relief that are available to us.
First off, what do I mean by non-monetary, equitable relief?  To me, that term includes the full range of remedies the Commission has at its disposal, beyond the ability to seek penalties and disgorgement.  When thoughtfully deployed, non-monetary remedies give the Commission latitude to craft an outcome that best matches the facts and circumstances of a given case.
So what are the non-monetary remedies that are critical to our enforcement efforts?  Today, I’ll highlight a few forms of non-monetary relief that are of particular significance – undertakings and conduct-based injunctions, and bars and suspensions.

Undertakings and Conduct-Based Injunctions

In civil injunctive actions, the federal securities laws permit the Commission to seek – and federal courts to grant – any equitable relief that may be appropriate or necessary for the benefit of investors.[2]  In practice, two of the most effective forms of equitable relief in Commission enforcement actions are undertakings, which require a defendant to take affirmative steps – either in conjunction with entry of the order or in the future – in order to come into and remain in compliance with the specific terms of the court’s order, and conduct-based injunctions, which prohibit a defendant from engaging in conduct that, while otherwise legal, poses risk of harm to investors in the future.  The Commission also has authority to impose similar obligations in administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings.[3]
For example, the Commission recently secured a conduct-based injunction in its settlement with Billy McFarland, who, according to the SEC’s complaint, fraudulently induced more than 100 investors to put over $27 million into his companies, including Fyre Festival LLC.  In addition to ordering that McFarland and his companies were liable for full disgorgement, the final judgment in the SEC’s matter against McFarland included a conduct-based injunction, enjoining McFarland from directly or indirectly participating in the issuance, purchase, offer, or sale of any security, except for his own personal account.[4]
With respect to undertakings, many require the settling party to retain a compliance consultant or monitor to make recommendations to the issuer and report to the Commission on terms specifically defined in the settlement papers.[5]  Such undertakings make it possible for an SEC action to seed change in a corporation’s processes in a way that serves the long-term interests of investors.  Undertakings are a forward-looking remedy; they are specifically designed with an eye toward what happens after the settlement.  So when they are well-crafted, they unquestionably provide unique benefits to investors in the long term. 
In addition to undertakings requiring the retention of compliance consultants or monitors, we have also tailored other types of undertakings to accomplish remedial objectives that were specific to the wrongful conduct at issue. 
In March, the Commission charged Theranos, Inc., a private company, and its founder and CEO Elizabeth Holmes with raising more than $700 million from investors in an elaborate, years-long scheme involving exaggerated claims about the company’s technology, business, and financial performance.[6] 
Aspects of the Theranos matter have been covered extensively in other forums.  But for today’s purposes, one of the most important elements of the Commission’s settlement with Holmes were undertakings that (1) required her to relinquish her voting control over Theranos by converting her supermajority shares to common shares, and (2) guaranteed that in a liquidation event, Holmes would not profit from her ownership stake in the company until $750 million had been returned to other Theranos investors.  In Theranos, the Commission confronted a situation where, because of the capital structure of the company, Holmes had nearly complete control of the company.  And given what we alleged had occurred, it was appropriate to seek relief that protected investors from potential misuse of that controlling position going forward.  The undertakings were designed to do exactly that.
In another example, late last week, the Commission charged Elon Musk, the Chairman and CEO of Tesla, with fraud for Tweeting a series of false and misleading statements about his plan to take Tesla private.[7]  The Commission also charged Tesla with failing to maintain disclosure controls and procedures with respect to Musk’s communications.  To settle the SEC actions, Musk and Tesla agreed not only to pay significant penalties, but also to a set of comprehensive undertakings.  If approved by the court, the undertakings will require, among other things, (1) Musk to resign as Chairman and be replaced by an independent Chairman, (2) Tesla to add two independent directors to its board, (3) Tesla to establish a committee of independent directors and adopt mandatory controls and procedures to oversee and Musk’s public communications about the company, and (4) Tesla to employ within its legal department an experienced securities counsel.[8]
 These undertakings specifically target and attempt to address specific risks – in this case, the potential harm to investors caused by Musk’s communication practices and a lack of sufficient oversight and control of those communications.  The undertakings were specifically targeted to put in place stronger corporate governance by increasing the independence of the Tesla board and imposing closer oversight and control of Musk’s communications.  I believe these carefully tailored undertakings serve the Commission’s investor protection mission by specifically addressing the misconduct at issue.   
In these examples, the overall package of remedies also included monetary penalties aimed at punishing misconduct, and the benefit of such penalties for deterring misconduct should not be understated.  But the equitable relief the Commission obtained was both forward-looking and precisely tailored to the facts and circumstances of the case, and for that reason, it stands to benefit investors over the long run.

Bars and Suspensions

In addition to undertakings, the Commission can also seek or impose other forms of forward-looking or remedial relief, such as officer and director bars and associational bars and suspensions.  Like undertakings, bars and suspensions are not a punishment.  Rather, they serve a critical prophylactic function – preserving the integrity of our markets and protecting investors by limiting the activity of known bad actors by removing them from the industry or preventing them from serving as officers or directors at public companies.
In actions authorized this fiscal year alone, the Commission is seeking in litigation, or has obtained in settlements, multi-year officer and director bars or industry bars and suspensions against hundreds of individuals.  Some illustrations of the bars sought or obtained include:
  • Bars we are seeking in ongoing litigation against the former CEO and CFO of one of the largest mining interests in the world, who allegedly misled investors about the rapid deterioration in the value of a business the company had recently acquired for $3.7 billion.[9] 
  • Bars sought against CEO and COO who allegedly misrepresented their company as a first-of-its-kind decentralized bank offering its own cryptocurrency to be used for a broad range of customer products and services.[10]
  • Bars secured in settlement with the former CEO of a NASDAQ-listed oil and gas company who received over $1 million of undisclosed perks and compensation in a variety of forms, including lavish social events, first class travel, and an office bar stocked with high-end liquor and cigars.[11]
  • Bars secured against the former CEO of LendingClub Asset Management LLC, who was charged with using the fund’s money to benefit LendingClub Corporation.[12]
  • And of course, we secured a ten-year officer and director bar against Elizabeth Holmes, and are seeking an officer and director bar in our ongoing litigation against Theranos’ former President, Sunni Balwani.[13]
It may not come as a surprise that many individuals as to whom we seek bars choose to litigate rather than settle with the Commission.  As such, bars can be a resource-intensive remedy for the agency.  But the flip side of the resources coin is a remedy that, like undertakings, can have direct, far-reaching, and positive effects for investors.  As such, obtaining bars and suspensions, when warranted by the facts and circumstances, are a high priority for the Division.

III. Civil Penalties and Disgorgement


I’d like to turn now to monetary relief.  Since 1990, when the SEC’s current penalty regime came into effect, the Commission has often levied large penalties against regulated entities.[14]  That was true again this year, when multiple Wall Street banks,[15] asset managers,[16] and other market gatekeepers, including a regulated exchange,[17] were assessed large money penalties.
The rationale behind assessing money penalties in actions involving regulated entities is relatively straightforward.  To preserve the integrity of our markets and protect investors, the Commission is charged with promulgating and enforcing rules governing certain of the business practices of the entities we regulate – including broker-dealers, investment advisers, asset managers, credit rating agencies, and exchanges.  Penalties are one of the primary enforcement tools we have to incentivize regulated entities to remain in compliance with the rules that protect investors.  Stephanie and I embrace this rationale, and you can expect us to apply it throughout our tenure as Co-Directors.
But the analysis with respect to corporate issuers with a class of securities registered with the SEC often involves additional considerations that don’t uniformly apply in matters involving regulated entities.  Such issuers are required by statute and regulation to file public periodic and annual reports and financials, and to have policies, procedures, and controls in place to enable them to satisfy their obligations concerning the accuracy, completeness, and timeliness of such filings.  Using enforcement to promote the integrity of issuers’ public filings – which are central to the sound functioning of our capital markets – is a critical part of our mandate.  So in matters involving corporate issuer misconduct, decisions about whether to recommend the assessment of penalties require careful and thoughtful balancing of many factors including, of course, the nature of the misconduct.
We also consider whether application of the Seaboard factors is appropriate.  This includes evaluation of the nature of remedial steps taken by the company, its own self-reporting and self-policing efforts, and the extent of its cooperation with the Commission and other law enforcement agencies.[18]
Over the last year, the balance of factors has led the Division to recommend substantial penalties against a variety of corporate issuers.  I’ll touch briefly on four examples:
  • In September, the Commission obtained a $20 million penalty from a publicly-traded biopharmaceutical company and two of its senior officers to settle charges that they misled investors about the company’s developmental lung cancer drug.  The Commission alleged that the company’s investor presentations, press releases, and SEC filings stated that the drug was effective 60 percent of the time, far higher than suggested by actual results available internally.[19]
  • The Commission obtained a $34 million penalty against Walgreens Boots Alliance, Inc., in an action against the company and two former executives for allegedly misleading investors over multiple reporting periods about increased risk that the company would miss an important financial projection that it had announced simultaneously with the announcement of its merger with Boots.[20]
  • Altaba, the company formerly known as Yahoo!, paid $35 million to settle charges that it misled investors by failing to disclose one of the world’s largest data breaches, in which hackers stole personal data relating to hundreds of millions of user accounts.   The Commission alleged that Yahoo!’s senior management was aware of the cyber intrusion, but failed adequately to investigate the breach or disclose it for a period of almost two years.[21]
  • And of course, the Commission secured a $20 million penalty against Tesla, whose governance failures allegedly enabled Musk’s fraudulent tweets.  As we alleged in our complaint, for years, Tesla had relied on Musk’s Twitter feed – with its 22 million followers – to market the company and disseminate corporate news and information.  But the company had no controls in place to ensure that his Tesla-related tweets were accurate and otherwise complied with the federal securities laws.
The penalties in these cases served a strong deterrent purpose.
That said, not every case warrants a penalty.  As a counterpoint, last December the Commission issued an order finding that the CEO and CFO of an exchange-listed biopharmaceutical company received millions of dollars in undisclosed perks.[22]   The company undertook to fully remediate material weaknesses in its accounting controls – and undertook to retain an independent compliance consultant should its remediation efforts fail.  The SEC’s order expressly acknowledged the extensive remediation efforts taken by the company, which included the institution of legal proceedings the collect repayments from its former CEO and CFO and replacing the firms that had provided or assisted with bookkeeping.  In light of these extensive remedial efforts, combined with the undertaking agreed to by the company, we determined that it was appropriate not to recommend a penalty to the Commission.
We made a similar judgment call with our recommendation in a case announced last week, which involved conduct by a publicly-traded pharmaceutical company that otherwise weighed in favor of a penalty recommendation.  We credited new management’s significant cooperation – including its self-reporting of the misconduct – with the Commission’s investigation and its proactive remediation efforts in deciding against recommending a corporate penalty.[23] 


While there is a careful weighing of factors with respect to penalties, the other primary form of monetary relief – disgorgement – is handled quite differently.  Even where a defendant or respondent cooperates and agrees to meaningful undertakings, it should not be entitled to keep its ill-gotten gains, which we are often in a position to restore to harmed investors. 
The Commission has obtained disgorgement in a wide variety of matters, including offering frauds, and most all FCPA resolutions.[24]  The Commission also obtained significant disgorgement in settlements with regulated entities that profited by their failures to adhere to the Commission’s rules and regulations. Earlier this year, for example, Deutsche Bank was required to disgorge more than $44 million of ill-gotten gains associated with its improper handling of pre-release American Depositary Receipts.  The Commission secured similar relief in matters against a number of large broker-dealers this year. 
And of course, in offering frauds, where individuals obtain money directly from investors through fraudulent representations, disgorgement is a central component of meaningful relief and often the surest way to restore at least a portion of investors’ losses.[25] 
As you probably know, the Supreme Court ruled last term in Kokesh v. SEC that disgorgement was to be considered a penalty for statute of limitations periods, and therefore the proceeds of misconduct obtained by a wrongdoer outside the statute of limitations were insulated from disgorgement.  The impact of the ruling has been very significant and will continue to be.  Take Kokesh, itself.  That case involved an investment adviser who misappropriated from investors $34.9 million through a long running scheme that spanned 14 years.  Of that amount, $29.9 million was misappropriated as a result of violations that occurred more than five years before the Commission brought its action.  In the end, Kokesh kept the vast majority of his ill-gotten gains, at the expense of innocent investors.[26] 
The impact of Kokesh has been felt across our enforcement program.  A few months ago, we calculated that Kokesh led us to forego seeking approximately $800 million in potential disgorgement in filed and settled cases.  That number continues to rise. 

IV. Conclusion

So what is the takeaway of all of this?  I think as you can see the Commission has at its disposal a wide variety of remedies and relief.  And in the Division of Enforcement we think carefully about what of those tools to recommend to the Commission in every case.  What we do not do is assess large penalties simply for the sake of counting them up at the end of the year   For that reason, the effectiveness of our program cannot be measured with resort to any one quantitative measure, but instead requires a nuanced and qualitative evaluation of our overall impact on achieving our investor and market integrity protection mission.
Thank you for your time today.
[1] The Securities and Exchange Commission, as a matter of policy, disclaims responsibility for any private publication or statement by any of its employees.  The views expressed herein are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Commission or of the author’s colleagues on the staff of the Commission.
[2] See Section 21(d)(5) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. §78u(d)(5).
[3]  See Sections 15(b)(4), 15(b)(6), and  21C(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. §§ 78o(b)(4), (6), and 78u-3(a).
[4] See Final Judgment as to Defendants William Z. (“Billy”) McFarland, Fyre Media, Inc., and Magnises, Inc., SEC v. William Z. (“Billy”) McFarland, No. 1:18-CV-6634-JGK (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 1, 2018).
[5] See Press Release 2018-184, SEC Obtains Relief to Fully Reimburse Retail Investors Sold Unsuitable Product (Sept. 11 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-184; Press Release 2018-222, SEC Charges Stryker A Second Time for FCPA Violations (Sept. 28, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-222.
[6] See Press Release 2018-41, Theranos, CEO Holmes, and Former President Balwani Charged With Massive Fraud (March 14, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-41.
[7] See Press Release 2018-219, Elon Musk Charged With Securities Fraud for Misleading Tweets (Sept. 27, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-219.
[8] See Press Release 2018-226, Elon Musk Settles SEC Fraud Charges; Tesla Charged With and Resolves Securities Law Charge (Sept. 29, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-226.
[9] See Press Release 2017-196, Rio Tinto, Former Top Executives Charged With Fraud (Oct. 17, 2017), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2017-196.
[10] See Press Release 2018-8, SEC Halts Alleged Initial Coin Offering Scam (Jan. 30, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-8.
[11] See Press Release 2018-13, SEC Charges Oil Company CEO, Board Member With Hiding Personal Loans (July 16, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-133.
[12] See Press Release 2018-223, SEC Charges LendingClub Asset Management and Former Executives With Misleading Investors and Breaching Fiduciary Duty (Sept. 28, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-223.
[13] See Press Release 2018-41.
[14] See Press Release 2010-123, Goldman Sachs to Pay Record $550 Million to Settle SEC Charges Related to Subprime Mortgage CDO (July 15, 2010), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-123.htm; Press Release 2016-128, Merrill Lynch to Pay $415 Million for Misusing Customer Cash and Putting Customer Securities at Risk (June 23, 2016), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/pressrelease/2016-128.html.
[15] See Press Release 2018-155, Citigroup to Pay More Than $10 Million for Books and Records Violations and Inadequate Controls (Aug. 16, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-155-0; Press Release 2018-108, Merrill Lynch Admits to Misleading Customers about Trading Venues (June 19, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-108; Press Release 2018-138, Deutsche Bank to Pay Nearly $75 Million for Improper Handling of ADRs (July 20, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-138.
[16] See Press Release 2018-167, Transamerica Entities to Pay $97 Million to Investors Relating to Errors in Quantitative Investment Models (Aug. 27, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-167.
[17] See Press Release 2018-31, NYSE to Pay $14 Million Penalty for Multiple Violations (March 6, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-31; Press Release 2018-169, SEC Charges Moody’s With Internal Controls Failures and Ratings Symbols Deficiencies (Aug. 28, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-169.
[18] Report of Investigation Pursuant to Section 21(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Commission Statement on the Relationship of Cooperation to Agency Enforcement Decisions, Securities Exchange Act Release No. 44969 (Oct. 23, 2001) (available at: http://www.sec.gov/litigation/investreport/34-44969.htm).
[19] See Press Release 2018-199, Biopharmaceutical Company, Executives Charged With Misleading Investors About Cancer Drug (Sept. 18, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-199.
[20] See Press Release 2018-220, SEC Charges Walgreens and Two Former Executives With Misleading Investors About Forecasted Earnings Goal (Sept. 28, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-220.
[21] See Press 2018-71, Altaba, Formerly Known as Yahoo!, Charged With Failing to Disclose Massive Cybersecurity Breach; Agrees To Pay $35 Million(April 24, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-71.
[22] See Press Release 2017-229, SEC Charges Biopharmaceutical Company With Failing to Properly Disclose Perks for Executives (Dec. 12, 2017), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2017-229
[23] See Press Release 2018-221, SEC Charges Salix Pharmaceuticals and Former CFO With Lying About Distribution Channel (Sept. 28, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-221.
[24] See Press Release 2018-215, Petrobras Reaches Settlement With SEC for Misleading Investors (Sept. 27, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-215See Press Release 2018-188, United Technologies Charged With Violating FCPA (Sept. 12, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-188; Press Release 2018-174, Sanofi Charged With FCPA Violations (Sept. 4, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-174
[25] See Press Release 2018-141, SEC Charges Failed Fyre Festival Founder and Others With $27.4 Million Offering Fraud (July 24, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-141; Litigation Release No. 24076, SEC Charges Operators of Private Real Estate Fund with Scheme to Defraud Retail Investors (March 22, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2018/lr24076.htm; Litigation Release No. 24241, SEC Charges Nevada Microcap Issuer and Individuals with Unregistered, Fraudulent Offering (Aug. 21, 2018), available at https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/2018/lr24241.htm.
[26] Kokesh v. SEC, 137 S. Ct. 1635 (2017) (Sotomayor, J.).

No comments:


Blog Archive

Ad Home

Follow Us

No one has ever become poor by giving, Please Donate

Flickr Images


Powered by Blogger.


Search This Blog

Find Us On Facebook

Random Posts

Recent Posts

Header Ads



Blog Archive


.. ... ..a ..Temp ..wc #anthrax #bacteria #campfire #ContraCostaMurders #deadattorneys #deadbanker #deadceo #deadlyequity #deadmormons #DeadRealtors #deadstudents #deadwitness #meningitis #UCSystem #WalnutCreekMurders 2010 48 Hours 5150 9/11 9/11 Connector 9/11 Investigation 9/11 Truth AB Acquisition ABC Abuse of Authority under Color of Law Acalanes High School Accel-KKR Accenture Accident Analysis Accidents Accord Group Holdings Active Shooter Events Active Shooters Adam Schiff Admission Scandal AdUps AE911 AEG AEG Facilities AFL-CIO Africa Air Disasters Airbnb Airbnb Mansion Party Airbus Group Airport Security Guard Murders Alameda County Sheriff's Office Alamo Alamo 1st Ward Alamo 2nd Ward Albert D Seeno Albert Seeno Jr Albertsons Alex Fagan Alfred J.R. Villalobos Alliant Insurance Services Alliant Insurance Services Inc Alston-Bird Amazon Americas Ameritech Amtrak Accidents Amtrak Media Amtrak Police Andrew Breitbart Android Anna Roth Anschutz Entertainment Group Anthrax Antitrust Antitrust Division Antivirus Terrorism ANTRAX Apollo Global Management Apollo Management Apple Computer Apple Fraud Ariel Investments Ariel Investments LLC Arson Arson Murder Arson Network Arson Tracker Arthur Frederick Goode III Asia Asset Forfeiture Asset Managers AT&T AT&T 7 T-Mobile Merger AT&T and 9/11 AT&T Antitrust AT&T Board of Directors AT&T Data Breach AT&T Fiber Optics ATF Athenian School Atlanta Attempted Murder attorney Attorney General Becerra Attorney General of New York Attorney James Greenan Attorney Licensee Profile Attorney Rick Kopf Attorneys Australia Automatic Data Processing Avia Aviation Aviation Accidents Aviation Accidents and Incidents Portal B of A Bacteria Bacterial Bacterial Warfare Bain Capital BakerHostelter Bank of America Banking BANTA Bar-K Bar-K Investors Barcelona Terror Attack Barista Barry Seal BART Base Realignment and Closure Base Realignment and Closure Commission Base Realignment and Conversion Bay Alarm Bay Area Bay Area Council Bay Area Homeless Bay Area News Group Bay Area Politicians Bay Meadows Park Bay of Pigs Bayareahomeless.com bayareanewsgroup.com Bechtel Bechtel Corporation Bechtel Group Belasco Theatre Company Ben Curry Benchmark Financial Services Inc Benne Bennett 9/11 Incidents Bennett and Alicia Driscoll Bennett and Johnson Bennett and Kinder Morgan Bennett and PG&E Bennett CIA Connections Bennett Claims Bennett Customer Bennett FBI Connections Bennett Incidents Bennett Johnson Bennett Litigation Bennett Losses Bennett Relatives Bennett v. Collins Bennett v. Fang Bennett v. PG&E Bennett v. SBC Global Bennett v. Southern Pacific BENNETT VS SBC SERVICES INC Bennett vsSouthernPacific.com Bennett Witness Benny Chetcuti Jr. Berkshire Hathaway Bickmore Risk Services Big Law Big O Tires Big Tech Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation Bill Graham Bill Johnson Bill McGlashan Bill Tauscher Bin Laden Family Bio-Warfare Biological Warfare Blackhawk Country Club Blackhawk Development Blackhawk Network Holdings Blackhawk Network Holdings Inc Blackrock Blackstone Group BlakeHunt Blame Pete Bennett Blogger Blogger Labels Blogger Logic Blogger Meta Tags Blogger Open Graph Blogger Posts Blogger Programming Blogger Themes Bloomberg BlueMountain Capital Management LLC Blum Capital Blum Capital Partners BNSF Board of Directors Board of Supervisors Boeing Bomb Squad Bono bootstrap Booz Allen Hamilton Boy Scouts BRAC BRAC Closure List BRACMurders Breitbart Breitbart Author Brian Cherry Bribery BrightSource Energy Broadway Pointe LLC Brown Act Buchanan Field Buchanan Field Crashes Buchanan Murders Building 7 Building Inspections Burglary BURLINGTON NORTHERN SANTA FE CORPORATION Bus Accidents Business Butte County Butte County District Attorney BYU CA-Berkeley CA-San Bernardino County CA-Santa Clara CA-Walnut Creek CalBay Calera Capital CalFir CalFire California Cities California Counties California Department of Elections California Department of Finance California Department of Justice California District Attorneys Association California Highway Patrol Special Operations Unit California Judicial Branch California Penal Code 118.1 California Public Employees' Retirement System California Secretary of State California Senate Legislative Homeless Activities California State Senate CalOHSA CalPERS CalSTRS CalTrans Camp Fire Canada Cancer Cape Coral Captain Neil Stratton Car Bomb CategoryIII Catellus Catellus Development Corporation CB Richard Ellis CBRE CBS 48 Hours CBS News CCCRMC CCSO Cecilia Greenan Ashcroft Centerview Capital Central Intelligence Agency Central Offices Cerberus Capital CHAPTER 4.5. Peace Officers Charles Kellogg Bobrinskoy Chase Manhattan Bank Cheesecake Factory Chevron Technology Ventures Chicago Chief Alldritt Chief Brian Addington. Pittsburg Police Department Chief Chris Wenzel Chief Christensen Chief Eric Christensen Child Support China China Ukraine Chinatown Chinese Hacking Chinese Hacking. Data Breach Chiquita Blvd CHP CHP Golden Gate CHP Investigations CHP Threat Assessment Unit Chris Butler Chris Wenzel Christopher Bultler CIA CIAI CIO Cisco Systems Inc City Attorneys City Concord City Council of Concord City Council of Walnut Creek City of Antioch City of Benicia City of Berkeley City of Cape Coral City of Castro Valley City of Clayton City of Concord City of Dublin City of El Cerrito City of Lafayette City of Las Vegas City of Martinez City of Oakland City of Orinda City of Orlando City of Palo Alto City of Pittsburg City of Pleasant Hill City of Pleasanton City of Richmond City of Roseville City of San Bruno City of San Francisco City of San Jose City of San Ramon City of Walnut Creek City Walnut Creek Civic Park Claimant Class Action Class of 75 Claycord Clayton Valley High School Clients Projects Connections Clint Eull Clinton Clinton Associates Clinton Foundation Clinton Murders Clinton Presidency - Related Club Locations Club Scene CNET CNET Conspirators CNET Overview CNET SCANDAL CNET Scandal Cases. CNET Scandal Victims and Connections CNET-Tanabe CNN CNWS Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival Cognizant Technology Solutions Corporation Cold Case Cold Case County Cold Cases Cold Cases Index College Admissions and Testing Bribery Scheme college admissions bribery scandal College Admissions Fraud Investigation Colony Global Acquisition Corporation Coming Soon Commerce One Commercial Real Estate Company Company Profiles Compass ComputerLand Computerland Corporate ComputerWorld Conclusions Concord Concord Murders Concord Naval Weapons Concord Naval Weapons Station Concord Police ConFire Congress Congressman DeSaulnier Congressman Mark DeSaulnier Connecting the Unions Conservationist Consolidated Fire Consulting Firms Contr Contra City of Walnut Creek Contra Cost Contra Costa Contra Costa Arson Network Contra Costa Bar Contra Costa Bar Assoc. contra Costa Bar Association Contra Costa Board of Realtors Contra Costa Board of Supervisors Contra Costa Cases Contra Costa College District Contra Costa Costa County Contra Costa County Contra Costa County Administrator Contra Costa County Board of Supervisors CONTRA COSTA COUNTY CITY ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION Contra Costa County Indictments Contra Costa County Regional Medical Center Contra Costa County Sheriff Contra Costa Department of Elections Contra Costa District Attorney Contra Costa District Attorney Mark Peterson Contra Costa Family Law Contra Costa Fire Protection District Contra Costa Grand Jury Contra Costa Hate Crimes Network Contra Costa Health Services Contra Costa Homeless Crisis Contra Costa Marine Patrol Contra Costa Murders Contra Costa Narcotics Enforcement Taskforce Contra Costa Narcotics Taskforce (CNET) Contra Costa Probate Court Contra Costa Public Library Contra Costa Republican Party Contra Costa School Districts Contra Costa Search and Rescue Contra Costa Sheriff's Office Contra Costa Sheriffs Office Contra Costa Software Business Incubator Contra Costa Superior Contra Costa Superior Court Contra Costa Times Contra Costa Watch ContraCostaBarAssociation.com ContraCostawatch.com Conviction Core Coroner Corporate Raiders Corporations corruption Cosmo Costa Bar Association Council Meetings County Contra Costa County Counsel County of Butte County of Contra Costa County of Marin County of San Mateo County of Santa Clara County of Solano County of Sonoma Court Cases courts.ca.gov CPU CPUC Crime Maps Criminal Cops crisis actors Crogans Bar Crunchbase CSAC-EIA Loss Prevention Services CSO CSS Tricks Cuba Cup of Coffee Custom Custom Search CVS Health Cyber-terrorism Cyberterrorism Czechia Dan Helix Dan Rather Dan Van Voorhis Dan White Daniel Horowitz Danville Danville Murders Danville Police Danville Stake Data Breach David Leslie Milne David Rockefeller Jr. David Twa David Wyatt Dorman DEA Dead Witness Dead Activists Dead Attorneys Dead Bankers Dead Bouncer Dead CEO's dead ceos Dead Constituents Dead Customers of Pete Bennett Dead Doctors Dead Employees Dead Homeless Dead Investors Dead Lakers Dead Lists Dead Litigants dead mormons Dead Musicians Dead Officers Dead Officials Dead Pilots Dead Politicians Dead Programmers Dead Public Officials Dead Realtors Dead Reporters Dead Soldiers Dead Student List Dead Students Dead Teachers Dead Tech ~ Programmers and Developers Dead Veterans Dead Witness Dead Witness Club Dead Witnesses Dead Witnesses Danville Stake Deadly Arson Fires by State Deadly REITs DeadWitness Deadwitness.com deadwitnesses Dean Witter Reynolds Deaths in Tech Delta Pacific Bank Department of Blum Connections Department of Defense Department of Justice Department of State Department of the Treasury Deputy Attorney General James M. Cole Deutsche Telekom AG Development Devils Breath DHS DHS Voice Diablo Magazine Dialysis Revenue Enhancement Dick Cheney Disability Discrimination Disbarred Attorneys Discovery Homes Discovery Sales Discrimination Examples dishonesty Division of Corporation Finance Divorce Divorce Case Index Divorce Enforcers DLA DoD Domestic Domestic Terrorism Don Tatzin Donald Rumsfeld Donald Trump donations DPD Dragon Global Driscoll Driscoll Murders Drownings Drugging DU Rounds East Bay East Bay Homicides East Bay Murder Series EAST BAY REGIONAL PARK DISTRICT East Bay Regional Park Police EBAY EBMUD Edgewell Personal Care Edward Siedle EEOC El Cerrito Police Department El Dorado County Election Fraud Electric Grid Electronic Warfare Elektion Fraud Elevation Partners Ellen O. Tauscher Ellinwood Farms Elliot Management Elliott Management Elliott Management Corporation Embezzlement Eminent Domain Complaint Emmon Bodfish Employed in Walnut Creek Endorsed by Mark Peterson Energy and Commerce Energy Sector Energy Sector Deaths Energy Terrorism Energy Transportation Systems Energy Transportation Systems Inc Energyterrorism.com English Speaking World ENRON ENRON - World Trade Center Equity One Equity Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) Eric Nunn Eric Salvatierra Erik Nunn Essex Property Trust Ethics Europe Executive Office of the President Executive Profiles Executives Experian plc Exploitation Explosion Explosion Cases Explosions Exporting America Facebook Fair Isaacs Fair Political Practices Commission Fake Visa Interview False Flags False Police Reports Family Law Fatal Fires Fatal Shootings FBI FBI Agent Frank Doyle Jr. FBI Agents FBI Agents Framed FBI Arizona FBI Counter Terrorism FBI Evidence Response Team FBI Rewards FBI School Bomb School FBI School Bomb School (West Coast) FCC FDIC Federal Federal Agencies Federal Bank of New York Federal Bureau of Investigation Federal Cases Federal Election Commission Federal Express Corporation Federal Funds Federal Grand Jury Federal Indictments Federal Prosecutors Federal Reserve Federal Reserve Bank Federal Reserve Board of Governors Federal Statutes Federal Statutes Home FedEx Corporation Feinstein fentanyl Fenwal Holdings FERC FICO Fidel Castro Filing False Reports Financial services Fires FIRST AMENDMENT COALITION FL FL-Gainesville Flowers For Sale Forbes Ford Motors Foreign Corrupt Practices Act Forensic Medical Group Forgery Fortune 500 FPPC Frank Doyle Jr Frank Doyle Jr. fraud Fraud Of The Court Fremont Group Fremont Group L.L.C Fremont Partners Fremont Private Holdings FREMONT REALTY FremontGroup.com Fresenius Fresenius Kabi Friends of Mitt Romney Ft. Myers Fusion GPS G4S Gambling Gary Collins Gary Vinson Collins Gas Pipeline Explosions Gates Foundation Gavin Newsom Gavin Newsome Gay Bars General Contractor George Bush George Driscoll gift cards GIS Global Terrorism Globalism Globalists Go Fund Me Golden Gate Capital Golden State Warriors Goldman Sachs Capital Partners Good Job Governor Newsom Governor of Massachusetts Governor Schwarzenegger Governors Grant Thornton Grant Thornton The Kennedy Assassination Green Valley Elementary Greenan Greenland Icecap Greg Passama Gregory Paul Anspaugh GWB H-1b H-1b Visa Hackers Haight Ashbury Free Medical Clinic Harvard Business School Hate Crimes Havana Havana Bar HCC Health Care Fraud Hedge Funds Hellfire Hercules Capital HGCG HICKS VS SBC SERVICES High Schools Hillary Clinton Hillary Rodham Clinton Hillside Covenant Church Hit & Run Hobbs Act Home Invasion Robbery Homeless Homeless Homicides Homeless Programmer homeless Support Links Homeless Victims homelesshomicides.com Homelessness Honest Services Mail Fraud Hong Kong Horowitz Connection HorowitzConnection Host Protection Insurance Hostile Takeovers House Committees House of Representatives House Transportation Committee Housing Discrimination Howard V. Golub HSI HTML% Huckleberry Botanic Regional Preserve HUD Hugh Smith Huma Abedin Hunter Properties Hunter Properties Inc I-131 Ian Murdock IBM IL illegal immigration Immigration Immigration Issues Immigration Solutions Immigration Success Immigration Tragedies Inc Inc. Incident Incident Maps Incidents Index India INDICTED CNET OFFICERS Indicted Customers Indictments Indonesia Infiltrators InfoWorld Infrastructure Insider Traders Insurance Insurance Fraud Intellectual Property International International Boulevard International Terrorism Investigations Investigative Journalist Investments Investor Fraud Investor Fraud Summit Iodine 131 Iraqi Freedom Iron Horse Trail Irrational Exuberance Ivanpah Solar Electric Generating System J Paul Getty Jacob Bauer Jailed Witness Club James Gilliland James Gilliland Jr. James Greenan Jamey Sheets Jared Tucker Jason Verdow JFK Assassination JFK Assassination. Southern Pacific JFK University Jim Coulter Jim Jones Jimmy Hoffa Job Joe Canciamilla Joe Lawrence John Ashcroft John F. Kennedy John Muir Medical Center John T. Nejedly Joint Chiefs of Staff Joint Powers Authority Jomorson Properties Joseph Arthur Behiel JOSEPH LYNCH Joseph P. Kennedy JP Morgan Judge Alsup Judge Barry Goode Judge Bruce Van Voorhis Judge Golub Judge Joel Golub Judge Peter Spinetta Judi Bari Judi Bari Bombing Connections Judicial Profiles Judicial Watch justice.gov Kaiser Kaiser Patient Kaiser Steel Kaiser Walnut Creek Kamala Harris Karaoke Karina Ioffee Kazakhstan Keadjian KEITHLEY v. HOMESTORE.COM KEITHLEY v. REALTOR.COM Ken Behring Kern County KEVIN D. LALLY Kevin Flanagan Khosla Ventures Kidnapping Kidney Kidney Failure Kidney Transplants Kiev Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP Kinder Morgan KinderCare Kirkland & Ellis KKK KKR Known to Pete Bennett Kohlberg Kravis Roberts Korean War KPIX KRON4 La Gonda Way Labor Condition Application Laci Peterson Lafayette Larry Ellison Larry Fink Las Lomas High School Las Trampas Creek Last Watch Law and Justice Law Enforcement Law Firms Lawrence Investments LBGT Lee County Legal Shield Legal Cases Legally Corrupted Lennar Lennar Urban LESHER COMMUNICATIONS Letters to City of Lafayette Leverage Buy Out LGBT LGBT Murders Limo Limousine Limousine Fires LinkedIN Posts Lisa Trapani List of Victims Litigation Live Nation Entertainment LLHS LLNL Lockerbie Lockheed Martin Locust Street Longs Drug IT Department Longs Drugs Longs Drugs Connections Lord Cobbold Loretta Hale Los Lomas High School Lou Dobbs Louis Lombard Lowes Lt. Dan Terry Lt. David Oberhoffer Lynching Lynchings Main Point of Entry Mainframe Designs Cabinets & Fixtures Mainstream Media Major Generals Mantech Map Mapbox Examples Maps Maps County of Contra Costa Maps1 Marc Benioff March4Trump Margaret Lesher Mark Coon Mark DeSaulnier Mark Peterson Mark Zuckerberg Martin Nelis Martinez Marvin Bush Mary Hobson Mary Nolan Mass Casualties Massacres Maverick Capital Mayor Dianne Feinstein Mayor Gavin Newsom Mayor Moscone Mayor of Walnut Creek MBS Modeling McAfee McFarland McGregor Scott McGregor W. Scott McKesson McKinsey & Company mcnamaralaw.com Mechanics Bank Medellin Cartels Media Media Contacts Medical Community Mellody Louise Hobson Mena Meningitis Meningitis Murders Mergers and Acquisitions Merisel MERRITT L. WEISINGER Metcalf Station methadone Meyers Nave MeyersNave Michael Flynn Michael Milken Michael Peevey Michael Peterson Michael Sevenau Michael Taugher Microsoft Microsoft Breaches Mid-Atlantic Arena Mid-Atlantic Arena Litigation Mid-Atlantic Arena LLC Middle East Milestone Holdings Missing Persons Mission Bay Mitt Romney Molly's Game MOMA Money Laundering Moraga moral turpitude Mormon Mormon Murders Mormon Polygamy Mormon.org Mormons Mortgage Mortgage Fraud Summit Moscow Mountain Lakes Mountain Lakes NJ MPA BOARD OF DIRECTORS MEETING MPOE Municipal Pooling Authority Murder Murder Conspiracy Murder Stories Murder Suicide Murder Suicides Murder Victim Murdered Moms Murders Murwood Elementary Music Music Deals MVSC MyVisaJobs N Main Street Nancy Greenan-Hamil Nancy McFadden Nashville Nate Greenan National Association of Realtors National CounterTerrorism Center National Rifle Association National Security Naval Air Station Oceana Naval War College NCIB NCIS NCR Corporation NCR Suicide Nearon Enterprises Nejedly NERC Network World Nevada Gaming Commission Never Forget New York City New York Real Estate NewBridge Capital Inc NIMDA NIMDA Computer Virus NJ No Place like Home Noinvest LLC nomoreh1b Nomoreh1b.blogspot.com nomoreh1b.com nomoreh1b.tech North Bay Associates North Korea Northcreek Church Northern California Northern District of California Northgate Capital LLC NOVINVEST LLC NSA NT NTSB NTSB Air Crashes NTSB Aviation Database NTSB Tracker NTSB_Pilots Nuclear Nuclear Engineering NYC NYFD NYPD Oakland Fire Department Oakland Murders Oakland Police Department Oakland Temple Oberhoffer OBIT Obituaries Obstruction of Justice Office of the Whistleblower Officer Dave Rangel Officer Involved Shootings Officer Lester Garnier Murder Officers Arrested Oklahoma City Federal Building Olin Corporation. Yankee Gas Services Co Olympic Place Onex Open-Mics Operation Varsity Blues opiates Oracle Oracle Corporation Oracle v. PeopleSoft Orange County Organizations Orinda Police Orland Other Outsourcing Outsourcing America Outsourcing Jobs Outsourcing Murders Overstock P2 Capital Partners Pablo Escobar Pablo Escobar. Central Intelligence Agency PacBell PacBell Info Systems Pacific Energy Development Pacific Lumber Pacific Southwest Airlines PACIFIC TELESIS GROUP Pacific Union International Pacific Union Real Estate Pamela Vitale Pandora Panera Bread Parental Abduction Parental Abductions Park Ave Park Smart Inc Parking ParkSmart Patent Attorneys Patents Paterson Teele and Dennis Patriot Act Patterson Paul Graves. Paul Hazen Pavlo Lazarenko PayPal PBS PCB PEDEVCO Pension Funds PeopleSoft Perfectly Framed Pete Bennett Pete Bennett Adversaries Pete Bennett Family History Pete Bennett Friends Pete Bennett Medical Journey Pete Bennett Resume Peter A. Darbee Peter Carver Bennett Peter Spinetta Peter Thiel Peterson Family Trust PG&E PG&E Court Proceedings PG&E Data Breach PG&E Ethics PG&E Executives PG&E Fires PG&E Indictments PG&E Maps PG&E Vendors PG&E Videos PG&E Witness PG7E PGE Pgewitness.com Philip Anschutz Phillip Marshall PHISMA Piedmont Lumber Pierre Nanterme PIMCO pionline.com Pipe Bombs Pipelines Pittsburg Playtex Playtex New York Stock Exchange Plaza Escuela Point-of-Sale Systems poison Police Police Corruption Police Department Index Politicians Polonium Polygamy Porter Goss Portfolios Portugal POTUS Pre-Paid Legal President Bush President Clinton President Obama President Trump Priva Private Equity Probate Fraud Profile ProLogis Prop 8 Providence Equity Partners Prudential Life Insurance Psychological Warfare Analyst Public Agencies Public Companies Public Corruption Public Investment Boards Public Law Public Officials Public Sector Pension Investment Board Pulse Nightclub Q-Fever Racketeering Racketeerni Radiation Poisoning Railroads Pipelines and Hazardous Materials Ravenel Enterprises Inc Ray Giacomelli Rays Lounge Real Estate Real Estate Fraud Real Estate Investment Trusts Real Estate Portal Realtor.com Red Hat Software Regency Center Regency Centers Regency Centers Corporation Regional Parking REITS ReMax Rep. Ellen Tauscher Reporters Research Research Portal Retirement Systems Reveal from the Center for Investigative Reporting Rewards Richard Blum Richard Lambert Richard Morgan Richard Nixon Richard_Stanford_Kopf Richmond Fire Department Rick Kopf RICO Robert F. Kennedy Robert Hoffman Robert Mueller Robert Vesco Ropes & Gray LLP Rossmoor Round Up Saloon Royal Canadian Mounted Police Rules of Professional Conduct Russ Darby RussDarby Russia Russian Russian Hackers Russian Hacking Russian Investors Russian Mafia Russian Oligarchs S Main Street SA SA Ken Karch Sabotage Safe Policing Safeway Safeway Inc Safeway Inc. Safeway Murders SAFEWAY STORES INC Salesforce Salt Lake City San Bernardino County San Bruno Explosion San Francisco Police San Mateo Bridge San Ramon San Ramon Fire San Ramon Unified School District San Ramon Valley FIre Protection District Sand Hill Road Sandoval Sanibel Island Santa Clara County Santa Clara DIstrict Attorney Santa Fe Santa Fe Industries Santa Fe Pacific Realty Corporation Santa Fe Pipeline Partners SAP Sare Regis Group SBC Global SBC SERVICES SBC SERVICES INC SBCGlobal SCE Scotland Yard Scott Peterson Scott Peterson is Innocent SE Search Page SEC SEC Master Page SEC Whistleblower SEC Whistleblower Protections Secretary of State Securities and Exchange Commission Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Sedgwick Sedgwick Claims Management Services Seeno Seeno Construction Seeno Indictments Sen_Feinstein Senate Senate Public Safety Committee Senator Barbara Boxer Senator DeSaulnier Senator Diane Feinstein Senator Dianne Feinstein Senator Mike Lee Senator Nejedly Senator Rainey Senator Rainey. City of Walnut Creek Senior Citizen SFBAR SFPD SFSU Sgt. Wenzel Sheriff Silicon Silicon Valley Silver Lake Silver Lake Partners Silverado Council Simon's Hardware Smart Voter smartphone hacks sniper SoCal Edison Soccer Moms Confidential Software Solano County Sony sos South America Southern California Edison Southern Pacific SOUTHERN PACIFIC COMPANY Southern Pacific Pipeline Partners Southern Pacific Railroad SOUTHERN PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY Southern Pacific Railroad. Southern Pacific Transportation Spc James Coon Special Counsel Spinal Meningitis Victims Springville UT Spygate Spygate Investigation SRVUSD