The Anatomy of Public Corruption

YVONNE ELDRIDGE Munchausen syndrome by proxy and once again Judge Peter Spinetta

Yvonne Eldridge

Other California Cases with Female Exonerees
https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/PublishingImages/Yvonne_Eldridge%20(1).jpg
Yvonne Eldridge had years of experience running a foster home in Walnut Creek, California, when, in 1987, she became one of the first foster parents to participate in a special program for medically fragile babies. Most of the infants in this program were born drug-addicted or with life-threatening conditions such as AIDS, and Eldridge was recruited for the program because of her experience and success as a foster parent. Eldridge was featured in a video produced by the San Francisco Department of Social Services to recruit foster parents and in1988, Nancy Reagan presented her with a “Great American Families” award at the White House.

In 1991, Oakland doctors alleged that Eldridge had intentionally interfered with the medical treatments of several of the children in her care.  The Contra Costa County District Attorney’s office investigated for a year, but failed to find evidence to support a conviction. But in November1992, at the urging of the doctors, the State Attorney General’s office took the unusual step of reinvestigating the case.

In the spring of 1993, prosecutors sought to revoke Eldridge’s foster care license. Investigators testified at an administrative hearing that she was responsible for the deaths of three children and tried to harm eight others between 1987 and 1991. Although it was not uncommon for the medically-fragile infants in the program to succumb to illness, the state claimed that Eldridge suffered from a rare psychiatric disorder called “Munchausen syndrome by proxy” that caused her to lie about the physical conditions of the children in her care in order to receive attention from medical professionals. As a result, doctors ordered unnecessary medicines and performed unneeded surgeries on some of Eldridge’s foster children.

The state accused Eldridge of piercing the intravenous line of one child and injecting sodium or potassium into others, causing them to suffer symptoms ranging from breathing difficulties to cardiac arrest.

In March 1993, California Child Protective Services took custody of the newborn son of Eldridge’s daughter, Amber, who was living with Eldridge, on the ground that the infant was not safe in Eldridge’s home. In April, Eldridge lost her foster care license.

In November 1994, a grand jury indicted Eldridge on two charges felony child abuse, and on December 3rd Eldridge turned herself in.

Eldridge’s trial began on May 8, 1996. Contra Costa Superior Court Judge Peter Spinetta had ruled that prosecutors could not introduce testimony about Munchausen syndrome by proxy because it might prejudice the jury. Without referencing the syndrome, prosecutors claimed that Eldridge regularly sought medical care for her foster children for mysterious health problems, and that two sick children began to thrive after being taken out of Eldridge’s home. The two doctors who testified against Eldridge were inexperienced in treating the severe medical conditions that the children were born with, and one of them had never even treated the children Eldridge was accused of abusing. As Eldridge’s appellate attorneys would later argue, the medical records of the children greatly contradicted the testimony of these two doctors. Eldridge’s attorney, Contra Costa County chief deputy public defender Bill Egan, argued that Eldridge was innocent and did the best she could with difficult cases. 

On June 3, 1996, Eldridge was convicted by the jury of abusing two medically fragile babies in her care. The judge allowed Eldridge to remain free on a $100,000 property bond because Eldridge was caring for her husband, who suffered from Lou Gehrig’s disease and attended the trial daily in a wheelchair.

On July 10, 1996, Eldridge was sentenced to three years in prison. The judge allowed her seven weeks to arrange care for her husband before she had to begin serving her sentence in late August.

Eldridge hired new attorneys, Zenia Gilg and Kristen Wohadlo, who filed a motion for a new trial on the grounds that her trial attorney, Egan, had not effectively represented her because he did not call family members, other foster parents, or medical experts who could have testified that the children Eldridge was accused of abusing were genuinely sick and that Eldridge had provided appropriate care. Eldridge’s attorneys also raised evidence that one of the doctors who had initially requested the investigation of Eldridge had a history of accusing foster parents of abuse. Eldridge was allowed to remain free on bond pending the motion for a new trial.

On January 16, 1998, Judge Spinetta ordered a new trial for Eldridge. In February, prosecutors appealed the ruling. In 2000, the California 1st District Court of Appeal remanded the case back to Judge Spinetta, saying that in order to conclude that Egan’s representation was constitutionally ineffective he had to decide that Egan had no tactical reasons for representing Eldridge as he did.

At a hearing on September 29, 2000, Eldridge’s attorneys argued that Egan had failed to call family and friends who could have corroborated Eldridge’s observations about the infants’ ailments. More significantly, Egan failed to find a medical expert to assist in Eldridge’s defense. Egan had asked Dr. Richard L. Oken, a pediatrician, to serve as an expert witness, but provided Oken only with the limited medical records that had been prepared by the prosecution.

In a declaration presented at the hearing, Oken stated that, had he seen the entire medical record, he would have been able to provide accurate medical explanations for the children's fragile medical conditions. Eldridge’s attorneys also argued that Egan failed to present evidence that one of the doctors who raised allegations against Eldridge, Dr. Marc Usatin, had previously made a pass at Eldridge, had been accused of a series of unwelcome sexual overtures directed at other patients and hospital staff, and had a history of accusing women of Munchausen syndrome by proxy.

On December 21, 2000, Judge Spinetta ordered a new trial based on the ineffectiveness of Eldridge’s trial attorney. The state again appealed the ruling. On Sept 20, 2002, the Court of Appeal upheld the decision. On January 8, 2003, prosecutors dismissed the charges against Eldridge.

– Alexandra Gross

Report an error or add more information about this case.

Posting Date: 9/28/2012
Share:

OBIT:Laurie Kessler

Share:

The Walnut Creek City Council Voter Fraud Investigation and DA Peterson the Felon

Cindy Silva heard Pete Bennett for the first time during the November 2, 2011 Council Meeting.  

Cnetscandal.blogspot.com

Several weeks later the defendant in Bennett v. Collins fell to his death.  During a March 2005 several 'friends" with badges arrived from Santa Clara County District Attorney Officers. 

Bought me a beer to coerce me?  


2018 Endorsements

My sincere thanks to all who have shown their confidence in me by endorsing my re-election candidacy for Walnut Creek City Council.


Who Supports Cindy


Organizations

East Bay Times
Walnut Creek Chamber of Commerce
Walnut Creek Police Association

Elected Officials

Walnut Creek City Council
Councilmember Rich Carlston
Councilmember Loella Haskew
Councilmember Kevin Wilk
Ron Cassano, City Treasurer
Former Walnut Creek City Council
Former Walnut Creek Mayors
Charlie Abrams
Bill Armstrong
Merle Hall
Kathy Hicks
Dick Hildebrand
Mary Lou Lucas
Gail Murray
Sue Rainey
Kish Rajan
Gwen Regalia
Bob Simmons
Sanford Skaggs
Gary Skrel
Other Elected Officials
Debora Allen, BART Director
Brandt Andersson, Lafayette Mayor
Newell Arnerich, Danville Mayor
Candace Andersen, County Supervisor
Ernie Avila, Contra Costa Water District Director/ Division 3
Catharine Baker, State Assemblymember
Elizabeth Bettis, WCSD Governing Board
Lisa Blackwell, Danville Town Council
Diane Burgis, County Supervisor
Ken Carlson, Pleasant Hill City Council
John Coleman, President, EBMUD
Kathy Coppersmith, Acalanes HS District Governing Board
Steve Glazer, State Senator
Dr. Michael Harris, Pleasant Hill City Council
Robert Hockett, Acalanes HS Governing Board
Cherise Khaund, MDUSD Governing Board (elect)
Beverly Lane, East Bay Regional Parks District director
Diane Longshore, Concord Mayor (ret.)
Mike McGill, Central Contra Costa Sanitary District
Sherri McGoff, WCSD Governing Board
Karen Mitchoff, County Supervisor
Sue Noack, Pleasant Hill City Council
Katie Peña, WCSD Governing Board
Barbara Pennington, WCSD Governing Board
Scott Perkins, San Ramon City Council
Richard Rainey, State Senator (ret.)
Sue Severson, Orinda Mayor (former)
Karen Stepper, Danville Town Council
Robert Storer, Danville Town Council
Dan Walden, WCSD Governing Board (ret.)
Amy Worth, Orinda Mayor
Appointed Officials
Janet Abrams, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Tom Bassett, Design Review Commissioner (former)
Joe Bologna, Arts Commissioner (former)
Polly Bradbury, Arts Commissioner (former)
Bob Brittain, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Fritz Brunner, Arts Commissioner (former)
Terry Camp, Design Review Commissioner (former)
Lonna Coleman, Arts Commissioner (former)
Daphne Cothren, Design Review Commissioner (former)
Glynnis Cowdery, Arts Commissioner
Cindy Darling, Planning Commissioner
Jodi Davenport, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner
Tom Donahoe, Arts Commissioner (former)
Jane Emanuel, Arts Commissioner
Carol Fowler, Arts Commissioner (former)
Neil Gerstner, Planning Commissioner (former)
Joseph Gorny, Design Review Commissioner
Eric Harrison, Planning Commissioner
Bill Hunt, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Lesley Hunt, Planning Commissioner (former)
Jerry Kaplan, Planning Commissioner (former)
Robert Kearsley, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner
Brian Kilian, Design Review Commissioner
Iasmine Klauber, Arts Commissioner
Brian Krcelic, Planning Commissioner
Dan Lawrence, Park, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Peter Lezak, Planning Commissioner
Mark Lopez, Design Review Commissioner (former)
Carla Ludwig, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Jon Malkovich, Planning Commission (former)
Dorothy McDonald, Design Review Commissioner (former)
Ian McLaughlin, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Ann Merideth, Arts Commissioner
Paul Meyerhofer, Transportation Commissioner (former)
Danny Milks, Transportation Commissioner
Allan Moore, Planning Commissioner
Jim Murray, Contra Costa Mosquito & Disease Vector Control District, Trustee
Art Oller, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner
Tom O'Toole, Transportation Commissioner (former)
Jim Pezzaglia, Arts Commissioner (former)
Bob Pickett, Planning Commissioner
Dave Powell, Planning Commissioner (former)
Steve Reiser, Planning Commissioner
Anna Sagastegui, Arts Commissioner
Nan Siegel, Arts Commissioner (former)
Kenneth Strongman, Transportation Commissioner
Rick Underwood, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Carlos Velilla, Design Review Commission
Phil Volkmann, Design Review Commissioner (former)
Clark Wallace, Contra Costa Assessment Appeals Board Member
Melissa Ward, Transportation Commissioner
Michael Weiner, Civic Arts Education Advisory Council (former)
Fred Weston, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner
Tom Worthy, Parks, Recreation & Open Space Commissioner (former)
Dominique Yancey, SRV Fire District

Individuals

Barbara Abernathy
Charlie & Janet Abrams
Stephen & Christine Abrams
Mitzi Abramson
Sue DiMaggio Adams
Debora Allen
Dan Scott & Kim Allen
Doug Alvey
Richard Amaro
Newell Americh
Candace Andersen
Beverly Anderson
Brandt Andersson
Tim Argenti
Bill & Navid Armstrong
Frank Arthur
Rebecca & Jared Asch
Jay Atkinson
Ralph & Sydney Austin
Jean A. Autrey
Ernie Avila
Catharine Baker
Christine & Larry Barclay
Mike Rippey & Gretchen Bartzen
Tom & Pat Bassett
Dick & Chris Bertrand
Elizabeth Bettis
Linda & Ed Best
John and Ann Bevan
Sandra Biagi
Les & Sharon Birdsall
Lisa Blackwell
Peter Blaney
Genevieve Blasius
Barbara Blum
Joe Bologna
David Bowlby
Polly Bradbury
David Bradley
Bob & Cindy Brittain
Mark & Maria Brown
Ron & Sharon Brown
Fritz Brunner
Diane Burgis
Buddy & Holly Burke
Kent Caldwell
Ken & Ginger Calvert
Terry Camp
Patrick Campbell
Clarita Cardenas-Velilla
Ken Carlson
Rich & Sue Carlston
Ron Cassano
David Clarke
Angie & Pete Coffee
John Coleman
Lonna Coleman
Robert Combs
Jason & Kimberly Cooke
Kathy Coppersmith
Nadia Costa
Daphne Cothren
Glynnis & John Cowdery
Paul & Kirsten Cox
Sal Crispi
Larry Crummer
Bev Cullen
Lee Culver
Richard Daniel
Cindy & Gary Darling
Joe Bunik & Jodi Davenport
Angela De La Housaye
Diane Longshore & Ron DeGolia
Ed & Denise Del Beccaro
Sunshine Deffner
Stephen & Carmen Deness
Todd DiMartino
Rebecca Doe
Fran & Steve Dogett
Tom & Nancy Donahoe
Nancy Donaldson-White
Paul Douglas
Art & Ardy Dreshfielld
Jill & Bruce Dresser
Dick & Carol DuBey
Jack & Sylvia Dudum
Bob & Wendy Duncan
Paul & Patricia Dunton
Pat & Bill Eich
Greg & Marcia Eiler
Eric Eisenberg
Barbara El Baroudi
Jane & Roger Emanuel
Teri Erickson
Kelly Farrell & Juan Carlos Espina
Jack Fallin
Dave & Norma Fellner
Paul Ferrari
Jack Fischer
Frederick Flint
Barney Fonzi
Carol & Ken Fowler
Gordon & Susan Freeman
Mary Fujii
Rich Gay
Janet & Norman Gee
Neil Gerstner
Jean Geyer
Kerynn Gianotti
Steve Glazer
Barry & Niki Gordon
Joseph Gorny
Terry & Sandy Goss
Bradley Griggs
Thomas Haas
Carol Haig
Merle & Bonnie Hall
Sam Colt & Anna Halvorson
Doris Hamel
Dr. Michael Harris
Eric Harrison
Richard Harmon
Hilary Harwood
Jean & Harry Harwood
Loella & Ralph Haskew
Cynthia Hatton
Ann Hawley
Georgia Hazard
Ron Hermanson
Kathy & Jerry Hicks
Richard & Lynne Hildebrand
Brian & Lyn Hirahara
JoAnn & Dave Hobbs
Marcie & Harvey Hochhauser
Bob Hockett
Billie Hopper
Barney & Jo Howard
Les & Cathy Howard
Sue & Skip Hoyt 
Linda Ashcraft & Richard Hudack
Marge & Al Hudock
Luman & Marilyn Hughes
Roger & Natalie Hughes
Bill & Lesley Hunt
Kris Hunter
Dick & Sally Ingraham
Natalie Inouye
Jacques & Yvonne Jakovleski
Stan Janczura
Howard Jarrell
Marge Joehnk
Lauren Jonas
Jo Jones
Kent & Marcy Jones
Barbara Jordan
Daniel Kanaan
Helen Kane
Jerry and Susan Kaplan
Doris Kawakami
Robert Kearsley
Kevin & Sharon Kelly
Bob Kelso
Sheryl & Ivan Kerr
Cherise Khaund
Brian Killian
Iasmine Klauber
Monica Daigle & Mark Kleisath
Diane & John Kopchik
Nick Kosla
Brian Krcelic
Shirley & Barry Krohn
June Krug
Beverly Lane
Robert & Nora LaPointe
Karen Large
Dan & Sandra Lawrence
Sheryl Lawrence
Margaret Leary
Janet Leask
Herbert Lee
Catherine & David Leutzinger
Sue Levins
Peter Lezak
Don Liddle
Janice Litvin
Stella Liu
Bev & David Loder
Dee Logan
Joyce Long
Mary Caden & Mark Lopez
Jerry Loving
Linda & Ron Loza
Mary Lou Lucas
Joan Lucchese
Carla Ludwig
Anthony (Tony) Lukaszewski
Alisa Mac Cormac
Tom & Diane Mader
Lisa Wrenn & Peter Magnani
Karen Majors
Jon Malkovich
Rosemary & Bernie Mark
Kelly & Elizabeth McCormick
Eugene McGrane
Dorothy McDonald
Mike McGill
Shauna McGlynn
Sherri McGoff
Winnie McIlvenna
Ian McLaughlin
Cynthia McMillan
Ann Merideth
Faye & Geoff Mettler
Paul Meyerhofer
Danny Milks
James Mills
Karen Mitchoff
Walter & Linda Moeller
Allan & Betty Moore
Bielle Moore
Jim Moore
Anne & Lyle Morton
Brian Murphy
Gail & Jim Murray
Jim Murray
Valeri Nagel
Mary Neff
Phil Neff
Gregory & Lynn Nerland
Tina Neuhausel
Sue Noack
Sally Nordwall-Echols
John Nutley
Patrick O'Brien
Kathleen & John Odne
Laura Odom
David Ogden
Andy Okumoto
Art Oller
David & Dolores Olson
William Oman
Ellen Osmundson
Tom O'Toole
Mike Palucki
Amy Pennington
Barbara Pennington
Scott Perkins
Jim & Yvette Pezzaglia
Bob Pickett
Gary & Jean Pokorny
Dave Powell
Bob & Jeanne Power
Trudy & Bruce Presser
Geri Pyle
Maria Rachidi
Sue & Dick Rainey
Kish Rajan
Robin & Art Rangel
Richard & Raina Ravitz
Helen Rees
Ruth Reeves
Gwen Regalia
Marc Kiefer & Connie Regalia
Steve & Wendy Reiser
Moe & Margie Richman
Vicki Roberts
Donna Robertson
Dan & Lynn Robinson
Dennis and Renee Ross
Eldon Rowe
Eric Rudney
Anita Sagastegui
Sara Schroeder
George Schulster
Mark Scott
Lauren Seaver
Marsha & Dick Servetnick
Sue Severson
Erin & Dan Sicotte
Nan Siegel
Judy Whelan & Bob Simmons
Barbara Simpson
Sanford Skaggs
Gary Skrel
Heidi Slocum
David & Sherry Smith
Karl Snover
Rick & Linda Spencer
Sarah Spindle
Mary Alice Stadum
Rob & Karen Stankus
Roger & Eileen Stephens
Tom & Kathy Stephenson
Karen Stepper
Peter Stern
Jim & Betty Stokes
Robert Storer
Bob Stratton
Ken & Melissa Strongman
Patricia Stull
Ann Marie & Tom Taylor
Tom & Sue Terrill
Glen & Joyce Densmore Thomas
Howard & LaVergne Thomas
Bart & Tatiana Tolley
Ping K. & Grace Tse
Rick & Sue Underwood
Alice Valle-Riestra
Lisa Van Dewson
Gayle Vassar
Carlos Velilla
Veronica Velilla-Wiesner
Phil & Pam Volkmann
Dan Walden
Clark Wallace
Melissa Ward
Robert Ward
Courtney Wassserman
Mary Watanabe
Dennis Winslow & Bonnie Waters
Glenn & Chelsea Wechsler
Michael & Denise Weiner
Mike & Kassie Wenzell
Fred & Carla Weston
Michael White
Kevin & Jill Wilk
Susan Williamson
Ernie Wintter
Trudy & Mark Wleklinski
Claire Levine Wolfe
Carly Wood
Ingrid Wood
Cynthia & Rick Woodland
Janiele & Kris Worswick
Amy Worth
Tom & Pat Worthy
Dominique Yancey
Mike Yeraka
Diane & Lance Young
Meredyth Young
Julia & Bill Younger
Eric Zell
Barbara Zodikoff

Share:

Anchor links for post titles

Popular Posts

Blog Archive

Labels

Recent Posts

Popular Posts

Labels

Recent Posts

Pages

Labels

Blog Archive

Recent Posts